Whitefish Bay's locally owned community pharmacy

Welcome to Fitzgerald Pharmacy!

Locally owned and operated by Hayat Pharmacy, we are committed to providing exceptional health care to meet the needs of our patients. We are proud to serve as your community pharmacy, continuing the long tradition of personalized care delivered by Whitefish Bay drug stores that came before us. This included the Dan Fitzgerald Pharmacy that once operated at the same location and opened in 1954. Fondly known as Fitzy’s during its 65 years in operation, customers would come for their prescriptions and stay to gather around the lunch counter with neighbors.


Today, our Fitzgerald Pharmacy is honored to continue these traditions and serve you through quality, compassionate and affordable care. Transfer your prescriptions today or call to schedule a consultation with our pharmacist, at our location or in the privacy of your home.

Ask us about our services!

Ask us about our free home delivery and special medication packaging that makes taking your medications easier - and safer. We can also help with your family's vaccination needs and answer any questions you have. And if you find that you or a loved one needs extra care, stop in. We carry a large selection of over-the-counter items, along with quality home medical supplies and equipment for direct purchase and special order. Our certified fitter is on site, or will make a house call by appointment, to be sure you have exactly what you need!   

Dan Fitzgerald standing with his delivery car
Dan Fitzgerald Jim Lou Ada and Rubinstei
Dan Fitzgerald - Fitzgerald's Pharmacy W

Featuring our soda fountain - Fitzy's!

Come for the care, then stay to enjoy a variety of delicious, locally made offerings from some of the best small businesses in our area. You will find Purple Door Ice Cream with Burke Candy toppings, our very own Fitzgerald Pharmacy coffee blend by Anodyne Coffee Roasting Co., and gourmet popcorn from Goody Gourmets. And yes, we brought back a selection of classic candies and counter sweets and there's outdoor seating too. We look forward to seeing you there!

Opening summer 2022!

424 E. Silver Spring Dr., Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

(414) 310-0005


Like our Whitefish Bay Pharmacy by Hayat Facebook page to get the latest news!


Hayat Pharmacy Plans to Fill the Void Left by the Closing of Fitzgerald Pharmacy in Whitefish Bay

Two months after the Whitefish Bay community mourned the loss of its beloved Dan Fitzgerald Pharmacy, another independent pharmacy has stepped up to fill the void. Hayat Pharmacy, which operates 16 locations in southeastern Wisconsin, plans to open a new business, Whitefish Bay Pharmacy by Hayat, in the location vacated by Fitzgerald, 424 E. Silver Spring Drive.


Hayat Pharmacy Plans New Location at Former Fitzgerald Pharmacy Space in Whitefish Bay

The former Dan Fitzgerald Pharmacy in Whitefish Bay could soon again be home to another pharmacy that would come complete with a soda fountain.